Kickstarter Tabletop Alert: Who Will Capture ‘The Pirate’s Flag’?

Reading Time: 6 minutes

The Pirate's Flag cover

All the pirates have gone in search of the missing Dread Captain—or more importantly, her ship’s flag, which will allow them to command the rest of the pirates. Anything goes in this madcap race for The Pirate’s Flag!

What Is The Pirate’s Flag?

The Pirate’s Flag is a CardLords game for 3 to 6 players, ages 9 and up, and takes 30 to 60 minutes to play. It’s currently seeking funding on Kickstarter, with a pledge level of $29 for a copy of the game. The game is suitable for kids both in theme and complexity, but be aware that there is a high level of “take that” involved.

New to Kickstarter? Check out our crowdfunding primer, and visit our Kickstarter curated page for more projects we love.

Pirate's Flag components
The Pirate’s Flag components. (Prototype shown) Photo: Jonathan H. Liu

The Pirate’s Flag Components

Note: My review is based on a prototype copy, so it is subject to change and may not reflect final component quality.

  • Game Board
  • 6 Pirate Ships
  • 6 Captain cards
  • 48 Action cards
  • Pirate’s Flag
  • 2 Dice
Pirate's Flag ships
Six unique pirate ships to sail! (Prototype shown) Photo: Jonathan H. Liu

The pirate ships are plastic, each with a small hole in deck for carrying the flag. I love that the ships are not only different colors but also have a different shape, which makes it friendlier for color blind players. It gives them a bit more character. The only thing I wish the game included (maybe a stretch goal?) is some sort of marker that you could keep in front of yourself so that you remembered which color you were, because I’ve played 6-player games where multiple people tried moving the wrong ship repeatedly.

Pirate's Flag captain cards
Captain cards include a couple characters from CardLords’ previous games. (Prototype shown) Photo: Jonathan H. Liu

The captain cards are double-sided: one side features just the illustration of the captain, and the other has the illustration and also the captain’s special ability. Most of the artwork in the game is thematically consistent, but there are two captains that stand out: the pirate cat (from Take the Gold) and the goat captain (from BattleGoats), both from previous games by CardLords.

The board is colorful and vibrant, with a winding path that snakes past docks, trading posts, and a large skull-shaped island in the center. Overall the illustrations are pretty good, though I’m not as impressed with some of the people on the cards.

How to Play The Pirate’s Flag

You can download a copy of the rulebook here.

The Goal

The goal of the game is to get back to the Dread Sea while carrying the flag.

Pirate's Flag setup
Setup is a cinch: put the ships at the start, the flag at the end, and shuffle the cards. (Prototype shown) Photo: Jonathan H. Liu

Setup

Give each player a pirate captain card, with the ability face-up. Each player chooses a ship and places it at the Dread Sea, just off the edge of the board. Place the flag on the Dread Captain’s ship at the other end of the board. Shuffle the cards and place them in a deck nearby—players do not start with any cards. Roll the dice to pick a first player.

Gameplay

Players will take turns rolling the dice to move their ships. At the beginning of the game, you roll two dice for movement, but after the flag has been claimed, everyone rolls one die instead. You may choose which direction to move (and you can jump down the waterfalls as indicated by the arrows) but you must move your full movement in that direction, with only a few exceptions:

  • If you pick up the flag from the water during your movement, you may continue your movement in either direction.
  • If you reach either end of the board, you continue your movement in the opposite direction.
  • You may stop to use a trading post, forfeiting the rest of your movement.
  • You may stop to battle a player if they are holding the flag.
Pirate's Flag trading post
At the trading posts, you may discard a card to draw two cards. (Prototype shown) Photo: Jonathan H. Liu

Any time you pass a dock (marked by the yellow lines on the board), you draw a card, up to a hand size of 5. If you stop at a trading post, you may discard a card from your hand to draw two cards.

Pirate's Flag movement cards
Many cards let you move ships or the flag. (Prototype shown) Photo: Jonathan H. Liu

You’re allowed to play one card per player turn, even when it’s not your turn, as long as the card doesn’t state otherwise. Some cards say that you can play an additional card on the same turn. There’s a huge variety of cards—each action card is unique—with some that have simple effects and some that will have random effects based on a die roll.

Each player’s captain also has a special ability that may be used once during the entire game—choose wisely! After that power is used, flip the card over to the art-only side to show that your power is no longer available.

Pirate's Flag captured
Flag: captured! Now to head back through the gauntlet of other ships. (Prototype shown) Photo: Jonathan H. Liu

As soon as somebody reaches the end of the path (where the Dread Captain’s ship is), that player takes the flag and puts it onto their ship. From then on, all players will roll only one die for their movement, and the player who first claimed the flag has a permanent hand size of 6 for the rest of the game.

Pirate's Flag battle
Time for a battle, as green tries to wrest control of the flag from red. (Prototype shown) Photo: Jonathan H. Liu

If you move into a space with a player carrying a flag, you may stop to do battle. Both players roll one die each, and the higher number wins. (Ties result in a re-roll.) If you take the flag, you get an additional roll for movement. If you lose an attack, your turn ends immediately.

Game End

The game ends when a player crosses into the Dread Sea (off the board) while carrying the flag—that player wins!

Pirate's Flag game in progress
Yellow is in the home stretch—will they make it off the board before somebody catches them? (Prototype shown) Photo: Jonathan H. Liu

Why You Should Play The Pirate’s Flag

On the surface, The Pirate’s Flag is a roll-and-move game—which I know makes a lot of people groan as soon as I mention it. Yes, you roll dice and move that many spaces on the board. Yes, there are a few spaces on the board that will kick you back or forward a space if you land on them. But don’t write it off just yet! There are some twists that spice up the gameplay and give you more agency—this isn’t just Chutes & Ladders with pirates.

The most obvious thing that prevents The Pirate’s Flag from being a boring roll-and-move game is the cards. There are many types of cards, and the fact that you can play most of them during any player’s turn makes for a lot of back-and-forth between players. There are cards that manipulate dice, cards that move ships around on the board, cards that manipulate cards, and some cards that let you take a gamble if you’re feeling lucky.

Pirate's Flag gambling cards
Some cards let you take a gamble on the effects. (Prototype shown) Photo: Jonathan H. Liu

Your pirate captain’s ability can also be really crucial—though you only get to use it once during the entire game. I’ve seen some players use it early, and then regret it later, but that’s better than forgetting to use it before the game ends.

The other major difference is the flow of the game: it’s not enough just to get to the end and grab the flag; you must take the flag back to the beginning of the path! With the waterfall shortcuts, you could actually make a run for the flag and get to it fairly quickly, but you won’t draw as many cards along the way. It’s also possible to hang around near the entrance, sailing back and forth past the docks to get more cards, and just wait for the flag to come to you. Since the person who first claims the flag gets a permanent boost in hand size, there’s some incentive to race for it, but no matter where you are on the board, the flag will have to get past you eventually.

Pirate's Flag gme in progress
Purple is in the lead to get the flag, though the other ships could take the waterfall shortcut to pull ahead. (Prototype shown) Photo: Jonathan H. Liu

I found that I liked this aspect of the game, and I’ve tried both strategies. If you sit near the trading posts, you can collect cards and swap out cards, building a good arsenal for when the flag returns. Plus, if you win the flag in a battle, you might be able to make a mad dash for the exit before everyone else catches up. (Note: rolling a “1” on your escape is not a good way to escape.)

Pirate's Flag cards about cards
Some cards let you get more cards, steal cards, or cancel cards. (Prototype shown) Photo: Jonathan H. Liu

The feel of the game does change significantly once somebody has claimed the flag. You’ll see a lot more cards being played, as people try to draw the flag closer to them, prevent the leader from getting away, or boost their own die rolls for battle.

Pirate's Flag game in progress
It can get really crowded when everyone’s after the flag but the attackers keep losing. (Prototype shown) Photo: Jonathan H. Liu

I think my only complaint is that this portion of the game can feel a little bit bogged down, because you switch from two dice to one for movement. I understand why—combined with some of the other card abilities, rolling two dice could allow the ship with the dice to get away much too easily—but it can lead to a bit of a quagmire where all the ships are clumped up together and various players keep pushing that clump away from the end. I’m not sure how you’d fix that—perhaps the path is just a little bit long? Or maybe it’s just the incorrect assumption that getting to the flag is the first half of the game, when it’s really more like the first third.

Pirate's Flag die rolls
Boost your own die rolls or subtract from somebody else’s with these cards. (Prototype shown) Photo: Jonathan H. Liu

When the winner finally crosses the finish line with the flag, it feels like a hard-earned victory! Running through the gauntlet of other pirate ships is definitely a challenge. It does seem kind of funny thematically that the pirates don’t start obeying the ship with the flag during the game, but maybe its power doesn’t kick in until you return to the Dread Sea.

With or without the cards, the game still does rely a good deal on luck: the luck of the roll and the luck of the draw. You can mitigate that luck somewhat by using the trading posts and choosing paths that let you cross docks more often, and there are many cards that can affect die rolls to your advantage. Ultimately, though, The Pirate’s Flag isn’t meant to be a deeply strategic game: it’s light strategy with a lot of “take that,” and can result in some ridiculous situations. I’ve played it with a range of people, both kids and adults, and it’s usually resulted in a lot of laughs as the ships (and the flag) are tossed about.

For more information or to make a pledge, visit The Pirate’s Flag Kickstarter page!


Click here to see all our tabletop game reviews.

If you’d like to stay up-to-date with all of our tabletop gaming coverage, please copy this link and add it to your RSS reader.

Disclosure: GeekDad received a copy of this game for review purposes.

Advertisements

Get the Official GeekDad Books!