Our fans commented at the product announcement thinking we were kidding! Nope, we were serious and a couple of us got review copies of Hasbro/Zynga’s first offerings of board game versions of their most popular online games.
The game I wanted to try more than any of the others was Words with Friends because my whole family loves the iOS version and we were all curious about how unique the board game would be…well, let’s be honest! It’s just a spin on Scrabble, right? I’m not going to mince words here…and I’m not afraid to say it because Hasbro makes both games!
When we tried out the Words with Friends board game this week, we really did set both games side by side and compare the two. People probably thought I was joking when I had suggested it a couple months ago. Let me give you the BLUF (military speak for “Bottom Line Up Front”).
BLUF: Words with Friends is a fun family board game that will make a great addition to your collection this holiday season. But I caveat this by saying that if you already own Scrabble, you’ll find that a board game version of Words with Friends is extremely similar and probably redundant for your collection.
Why did we all get addicted to online word games like Words with Friends? Let me count the ways:
- The “shuffle” capability. You hit that shuffle button enough times and the word ideas pop out at you!
- Automatic scorekeeping
- Instant dictionary: the game will instantly tell you whether the word you attempted is in its dictionary.
So if I wanted a board game version, I’d break out our Scrabble board game. My family already owns Scrabble and we enjoy playing it on cold winter evenings when it’s getting dark by four ‘o clock. But if you don’t own Scrabble yet, definitely consider Words with Friends. I don’t need to go over how Scrabble works for this audience, so I will move right on to how Words with Friends worked out for our family.
What Comes in the Box
- Game board
- Four curved racks to hold tiles
- 104 game tiles
- A handy drawstring cloth storage bag for the tiles and racks
- Rule sheet
- Digital enhancements code for an online Words with Friends account
Side by Side Comparison
The Words with Friends letter tiles (translucent plastic) are smaller and less substantial than the Scrabble tiles (wooden). I wonder how long it will be before the paint begins to wear off the letters. The Words with Friends board seemed flimsier than the Scrabble board we had. The Scrabble board has finished edges, while the Words with Friends board does not. The Words with Friends board arrived folded in half and it took several minutes for the board to lie flat.
Hasbro is planning a “Luxe” version of this board game (retailing for $39.99) with higher quality pieces, a rotating board and a mobile device holder on the tile rack (!)
The picture below will make it clear that the special spaces (such as “Double Letter” and “Triple Word”) on the two games’ boards are laid out differently. You will also see that the points allocated to the individual letters are different, so you will not have the exact same score experiences.
Despite all these differences, my sons and I enjoyed a couple of great games! My 10 year old son — my “math” son — really enjoys the challenge of maximizing his points with a single word, using the letters “J”, “Z” and/or “Q” , attempting to put them on a “Triple Letter” space while the word flows into the “Triple Word” space. Language arts skill-building at its best!
And might I add that taking turns as scorekeeper really helped build those math skills, especially for my 2nd grader!
Words with Friends has a suggested age range of 13+, but my 7- and 10-year-old sons not only really enjoy the game, but often score higher than I do. It retails for $19.99 and will make a great gift this holiday season!
Do you plan to make the leap from the virtual world into the board game?