Kickstarter Tabletop Alert: ‘Darkness: A Game of Ancient Mysticism’

Gaming Kickstarter Reviews Tabletop Games

Darkness Card Game

Mystics vie for control over strange relics and artifacts to gain power—but beware the Darkness!

What Is Darkness?

Darkness is a card game by Taylor Hayward for 2 to 5 players, ages 8 and up, and takes about 30 minutes to play. It’s currently seeking funding on Kickstarter, with a pledge level of $22 for a copy of the game. The game involves some bidding and light bluffing and is suitable for kids—despite the somewhat ominous voiceover in the Kickstarter video, the game itself doesn’t feel particularly spooky.

New to Kickstarter? Check out our crowdfunding primer, and visit our Kickstarter curated page for more projects we love.

Darkness Card Game components
For a game called Darkness, the components sure are colorful! (Prototype shown) Photo: Jonathan H. Liu

Darkness Components

Note: My review is based on a prototype copy, so it is subject to change and may not reflect final component quality. Stretch goals may add more cards to the game and increase the quality of the materials.

  • 75 Animal Spirit cards (15 per player)
  • 65 Artifact cards (12 each of 5 types)
  • 20 Relic cards (in 3 types)
  • 6 Darkness cards

The prototype uses the Euro-style half-sized cards and came in a small tuckbox, about twice the thickness of a standard deck box. I like compact games generally, but putting the half-size cards into a full-sized deck box made it hard to keep the various cards sorted without resorting to bagging half of them. The box itself is very plain and unassuming—just a black box with the words “Darkness Card Game” on it—though I see the $20k stretch goal is upgraded box artwork.

Darkness Card Game animal spirit cards
Animal spirit cards. (Prototype shown) Photo: Jonathan H. Liu

The cards themselves are lovely, though: the animal spirit cards are vibrant and detailed, with mystical symbols woven into the artwork. Each color also has its own icon, used in the top left and bottom right corners, making it possible for color blind players to distinguish colors on the artifact and relic cards. (Though the white-on-yellow icon may be a little trickier to see.)

The artwork on the artifact cards is a little less polished but still fits the theme of ancient stone artifacts. Each card has two circles in the top left corner, one large and one small, each with a different color and its corresponding icon.

The Kickstarter video shows some illustrations of various mystics; these are not seen in the game itself, which is a shame. I’m not sure where exactly they would fit in the game itself, but it’s odd to see those illustrations (and that colorful mystic in the top banner image) but not actually have them in the game itself.

How to Play Darkness

You can download a print and play version here, which includes the rulebook.

The Goal

The goal of the game is to score the most points by collecting sets of artifacts, as well as other relics.

Darkness card game setup
Setup for a 5-player game: 11 Artifacts, 4 Relics. (Prototype shown) Photo: Jonathan H. Liu


Each player gets a full set of 15 animal spirit cards, which includes 3 cards each in 5 colors.

Shuffle the relic cards and reveal 3 or 4 (depending on player count).

Shuffle the artifact cards, and remove a certain number depending on the player count. Each round, you will deal out a number of artifact cards face-up in a circle depending on the player count. For instance, in a five-player game, you set out 11 artifact cards.


Darkness takes place in 6 rounds, and each round has three bidding phases, then a resolution phase.

Play is simultaneous so there is no first player.

Darkness card game bidding
Cards are revealed after the first bidding phase. (Prototype shown) Photo: Jonathan H. Liu

In the first bidding phase, each player secretly chooses 3 animal spirit cards to play face-down; all players reveal their cards simultaneously. In the second phase, each player chooses 2 animal spirit cards, and in the third phase each player chooses 1 animal spirit card, revealing them in the same way.

Darkness Card Game artifact cards
There are five types of artifacts. (Prototype shown) Photo: Jonathan H. Liu

Each artifact card has two colors in the top corner: the color in the larger circle on top is the main color, and the other color is the secondary color. For each artifact, the player with the most cards of the main color claims the artifact. If there’s a tie for the main color, then the tied player with the most of the secondary color claims it. If that’s still a tie, the artifact is discarded and nobody gets it. Award all of the artifacts in this manner.

Darkness Card Game darkness cards
Darkness cards will harm players who are ahead. (Prototype shown) Photo: Jonathan H. Liu

There are also darkness cards mixed into the artifact deck: each darkness card has four colored rectangles at the top (usually three in a matching color and a fourth of a different color). If anyone has played matching animal spirit cards, the darkness card is dispelled and set next to the player who dispelled it. (In the photo above, the player at the bottom left dispelled the darkness card with 3 blue cards and 1 yellow card.) Otherwise, the darkness card is set aside in an area called the Veil. If at any time 3 or more darkness cards are in the Veil, darkness falls and there are consequences: all players discard artifacts down to the number held by the player with the fewest artifacts, and then the darkness cards are discarded from the Veil.

Finally, players resolve relics. Each relic shows five colored rectangles. If you are the only player who played cards matching those rectangles, you claim the relic. If there are ties, the relics remain for the next round. After all relics have been resolved, refill the row if necessary.

Darkness Card Game relic cards
Relic cards can offer special abilities or give you points. (Prototype shown) Photo: Jonathan H. Liu

There are three types of relics: gems, masks, and rings.

  • Gem: worth 3 points at the end of the game.
  • Mask: discard to keep the first two cards played in a round face-down instead of revealing them.
  • Ring: discard to swap out a card you’ve played with one in your hand after the last play phase.

At the end of a round, deal out more artifacts for the next round, and all players pick up their animal spirit cards.

Darkness card game phase 3
At the end of bidding,
every player has 6 cards revealed. (Prototype shown) Photo: Jonathan H. Liu

Game End

The game ends after six rounds—there will be no more artifacts to deal out. Each gem is worth 3 points. (Masks and rings are not worth points.) Artifacts are sorted into sets of the same type, and scored based on the size of each set. For instance, a collection of 4 obelisks is worth 7 points, and a collection of 7 obelisks is worth 22 points.

Darkness Card Game scoring cards
A scoring reference card shows the point values for different sets. (Prototype shown) Photo: Jonathan H. Liu

The highest score wins, with ties going to the player who dispelled the most darkness cards.

Why You Should Play Darkness

Darkness is a clever little bidding game that’s easy to set up and teach. The artwork on the animal spirit cards is lovely, though the packaging itself isn’t as exciting (at least not yet). Though the game does have an “ancient Northern Europe” theme, it is primarily an abstract set-collection game—I didn’t particularly feel like I was a mystic calling upon powers of animals so much as somebody bidding at an auction.

The three-phase bidding allows for a little bit of bluffing and maneuvering, but since you play fewer and fewer cards in subsequent phases, you can only shift so much. For instance, you could reveal three of the same color in the first phase, stating to everyone which artifacts you’re competing for and daring them to match you. Or you could reveal three different colors, hedging your bets and masking your true intentions—because, in fact, over the next two phases, it might turn out that you’re bidding heavily on something else entirely!

Darkness Card Game sets
The more artifacts of the same type, the more points you’ll get. (Prototype shown) Photo: Jonathan H. Liu

There are always several things to consider when bidding: the number of artifacts of any particular color, the types of artifacts you already hold, the colors needed to collect a relic, and whether there are any darkness cards to dispel. Because the artifacts are randomized, sometimes you may end up with several that have the same main color, and then some number of secondary colors. Winning in that main color could be extremely valuable—but it’s also likely that more players will be competing for them. Do you bid three in the main color and three in one of the secondary colors to guarantee that nobody else wins those? On the other hand, relics require a combination of five cards in three different colors—so if you use a 3 + 3 strategy, then you’re guaranteed not to get a relic.

Darkness cards kind of serve as a catch-up mechanic: if you’re behind, you don’t care if everyone has to discard artifacts, so you might as well let the darkness build up. If you’re ahead, you need to make sure that darkness doesn’t pile up—but dispelling darkness cards forces you to spend cards of a certain color, and if that doesn’t line up with any artifacts or relics, then that can be quite costly.

The downside, though, is that because the darkness cards are randomly shuffled into the artifacts deck, they may not come at the right time for that catch-up mechanic to work. We had a game where many of the darkness cards showed up early, and so some players dispersed them because they thought they might be ahead and didn’t want to risk losing artifacts. But then there weren’t enough darkness cards left to take down the leader later in the game.

We also found that using the 3+3 strategy can be quite effective if you manage to pull it off early in the game and get a head start on many artifacts. Once you’re ahead, you can use the 3+3 to ensure that either you get artifacts or they’re discarded, preventing other players from catching up to you. As with some other simultaneous selection games (like Go Nuts for Donuts), if you were the only one who managed to collect something early on, you can potentially win if you prevent everyone else from getting anything for the rest of the game. The only solution appears to be to let darkness cards pile up so you are forced to spend cards to deal with them … but they might regret it if they become the leader!

With fewer than five players, you remove some of the artifact cards, so there’s a little bit of random chance in which artifacts appear, and how many there are of each one. With five players, at least you know that there are 12 of each one, though it will be extremely difficult to acquire a full set of anything.

Darkness Card Game animal spirit cards
Each player has three of each animal spirit. (Prototype shown) Photo: Jonathan H. Liu

Ultimately, I think Darkness is a fun, quick game, but I’m not sure that it really connects me to the theme. The title isn’t particularly evocative (just try searching for “Darkness” on BoardGameGeek and see how many games you turn up) and the game doesn’t really feel like it’s playing out a story of any sort. If you really love the theme seen in the Kickstarter video and you want to feel like a mystic harnessing the power of animals … it might not satisfy that desire. But if you like the idea of a bidding and bluffing that you can fit in your pocket, Darkness might be a good fit for you.

For more information or to make a pledge, visit the Kickstarter page!

Click here to see all our tabletop game reviews.

If you’d like to stay up-to-date with all of our tabletop gaming coverage, please copy this link and add it to your RSS reader.

Disclosure: GeekDad received a copy of this game for review purposes.

Liked it? Take a second to support GeekDad and GeekMom on Patreon!