Review – Batman #78: Reunion Island

Comic Books DC This Week
Batman #78
Batman #78 variant cover, via DC Comics.

Batman #78 – Tom King, Writer; Clay Mann, Artist; Tomeu Morey, Colorist

Ratings:

Ray – 9/10

Ray: What’s the only thing more frustrating than a crushing cliffhanger showing us the likely death of a beloved character? Batman #78 being delayed a week, then taking a detour into a completely different story! Don’t look for answers about the death of Alfred Pennyworth in this issue, but the good news is that Tom King is such a good writer that he can keep us invested in the minutiae of the Batman/Catwoman relationship even with that agonizing cliffhanger hanging over our heads.

This interlude takes place on a tourist island as Selina looks after a recovering Bruce. He’s physically healed, but far from ready to return to confront Bane. We’ve seen Bruce broken down before, but something about this time is different – he almost seems unconcerned with what happened at times, and it’s Selina who has to prod him out of a semi-distracted state to focus on the crisis facing him. It’s an odd way of approaching Bruce, but I imagine being left to die by your alternate-reality father can do that.

Batman #78 interior page
Batcat beginnings. Via DC Comics.

The meat of this issue isn’t in the action scenes – there’s only a few, mostly Bruce and Selina training – but in the quiet dialogue between Bruce and Selina. This is the first time they’ve talked about her decision to leave and how he reacted in the aftermath, and King seems to be leaving the door wide open to a reunion. Selina was clearly pained by her decision and for the first time she expresses to Bruce why she actually left. Bruce has an odd fatalistic approach to the whole thing, as if he knew the universe would never allow him to be happy. It’s not my favorite take on Batman, since I tend to believe most writers make him more cynical and depressed than he actually is. But this issue seems to be about Bruce working his way out of it. Clay Mann’s art is absolutely stunning, especially in the nature scenes on the island, and he’s a near-perfect match for King. If this is a preview of what the two have cooking in their upcoming Batman/Catwoman series, count me in.

Corrina: The art is stunning and lovely and makes Selina and Bruce beautiful on every page without objectifying either of them. I especially love the nod to Magnum P.I. with Bruce’s disguise.

As for the story? The art makes me feel what’s going on between them. The dialogue makes me feel disconnected from them.

To find reviews of all the DC issues, visit DC This Week.

Disclaimer: GeekDad received this comic for review purposes.

Liked it? Take a second to support the GeekFamily Network on Patreon!

4 thoughts on “Review – Batman #78: Reunion Island

  1. 13 year old son is held hostage by his insane grandfather from another timeline and Bane*
    Batman is on a vacation.Some people don’t deserve kids .
    Bruce is pure trash. DC should be ashamed of herself! What a JOKE Bruce is!

    1. While I can see why people disagree with some of the story decisions taken here, Bruce has spent much of the last few issues catatonic and recovering. He’s still far below the physical peak he needs to fight Bane, and there’s no indication he knows anything about Damian or Alfred right now. I expect he’ll find out next issue and that’ll push things into high gear.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *